The Global Database Fallacy: Disdain for Rights + Numerosity + Secrecy = Steroidal Black Box

Originally posted on Music Technology Policy:
You’ve probably heard a lot about the gut wrenching need for a “global rights database” because “music licensing is broken”.  It sounds like of like a political campaign advertisement, right? Music licensing is broken Let’s drain the swamp And protect the future for our children Let’s get something straight…

Smoking Gun? Spotify “Accrued Fees To Copyright Holders” Now at 146 Million

As the unlicensed unpaid song fiasco with Victory Records indicated last week, and as I illustrated with my own catalogue in July,  Spotify and other streaming services have a serious problem with unpaid and unlicensed songs. Estimates on the amount of unpaid royalties range from $50 – $150 million dollars.  A source just provided us… Continue reading Smoking Gun? Spotify “Accrued Fees To Copyright Holders” Now at 146 Million

Turnabout is Fair Play: $100 Million Dollars in Unpaid/Unlicensed Spotify Songwriter Royalties Demands Investigation

Spotify’s $100 Million Problem Billboard magazine estimates that Spotify and other streaming services have as much as $100 million dollars in unpaid songwriter royalties and documents provided to us confirm that Spotify had more than $140 million in “unpaid fees to copyright owners” at the end of 2014.  While these kind of “unmatched” and unpaid balances are… Continue reading Turnabout is Fair Play: $100 Million Dollars in Unpaid/Unlicensed Spotify Songwriter Royalties Demands Investigation

NY State Abandoned Property Law and Spotify’s Unpaid Songwriter Royalties Crisis

In May of 2004 NY State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer announced that he had settled with the major record labels to pay out $50 million dollars in unpaid royalties.   The action was driven by attorney Bob Donnelly.  As The NY Times reported at the time: Mr. Donnelly encouraged Mr. Spitzer to use New York… Continue reading NY State Abandoned Property Law and Spotify’s Unpaid Songwriter Royalties Crisis

Spotify Broke the Law on Songwriter Licenses, Therefore Rights Holders Have to Build another Database?

Spotify has put quite an interesting  spin on its failure to license or pay on as much as 25% of the songs on its service. Quoting from the Wall Street Journal We want to pay every [fraction of a] penny, but we need to know who [sic] to pay,” Spotify spokesman Jonathan Prince said in… Continue reading Spotify Broke the Law on Songwriter Licenses, Therefore Rights Holders Have to Build another Database?

Trichordist Right On Spotify Black Box, @BerkleeCollege Transparency Report Wrong

This is just a quick reminder for those of you keeping score.  The Berklee College Transparency Report got it wrong on streaming services.  The Berklee College of Music asserted that songwriter streaming royalties were getting lost in HFA. We asserted that the problem was likely at Spotify because Spotify is required by law to obtain licenses,… Continue reading Trichordist Right On Spotify Black Box, @BerkleeCollege Transparency Report Wrong

Spotify Has Apparently Failed to License, Account and Pay on More than 150 Cracker and Camper Van Beethoven Songs

Everyone in the music industry is abuzz with the news that Spotify failed to license much of the Victory Records song catalogue. Spotify failed to pay royalties on these songs. After Victory Records went public Spotify pulled the entire catalogue Spotify spokesperson Jonathan Prince was quick to say this: “We want to pay every [fraction… Continue reading Spotify Has Apparently Failed to License, Account and Pay on More than 150 Cracker and Camper Van Beethoven Songs

Aurous has nothing to do with SOPA | The Illusion of More

In fact, when the lawsuit was first announced, The Trichordist rather humorously (though not at all facetiously) announced an “office betting pool” as to how soon the Electronic Frontier Foundation would file an amicus brief on behalf of Aurous. And while no serious IP attorney may reasonably defend Aurous against the infringement claims, that hasn’t… Continue reading Aurous has nothing to do with SOPA | The Illusion of More