Skip to content

The Trichordist

Artists For An Ethical and Sustainable Internet #StopArtistExploitation

  • || Comment Policy and Copyright ||
  • || About ||
  • More
    October 18, 2019October 18, 2019 by thetrichordist

    Guest Post: @ericdharvey Misses Music Twitter’s Defining Feature: Refuse Licenses and Pay Zero Royalties via @ArtistRights Watch

    by Chris Castle

    Eric Harvey has a great must-read article in Pitchfork about what he describes as “Music Twitter” (“How Twitter Changed Music“).  Mr. Harvey makes that case that Twitter was designed with both music and the music business in mind.  That is certainly true.  Twitter couldn’t be a more perfect way for pop and rap stars to connect with their fans and introduce new music.  If willing to put in the time (aka free labor for Twitter), artists from any genre can find it useful.  Unbelievable numbers of recordings are promoted, linked, streamed and talked about on Twitter.

    Mr. Harvey makes a point that many of us probably didn’t know:

    When Twitter was dreamed up, in fact, it was with music in mind. “This is why we built this thing! For concerts and music shows!” Noah Glass told fellow co-founder Jack Dorsey in 2006, according to Nick Bilton’s book, Hatching Twitter. At that point, when the site had only a handful of users, Glass and Dorsey road-tested Twitter at Coachella and attempted a partnership with the 2007 VMAs. As the site grew in popularity, Bilton recounts, pop stars made pilgrimages to the company’s modest San Francisco headquarters, like when a couple of Twitter engineers “found a member of the band blink-182, half-asleep and half-drunk, pouring a small bottle of gin into a bowl of Fruity Pebbles cereal, then chowing down on breakfast.”

    But after you read the post, I think you may realize that there’s a dog that didn’t bark–despite the fact that some of Jack Dorsey’s best friends may be musicians, Twitter has consistently refused to even accept the premise that the site needs licenses and should pay royalties.  However “intertwined” Twitter may be with the music business, the company steadfastly refuses to acknowledge that value by respecting business of the artists, songwriters, producers, musicians and vocalists who drive what Mr. Harvey shows pretty conclusively is a big chunk of Twitter’s value.

    Mr. Harvey dives into the many connections between the company’s founders who designed their product to free ride on the artists they claim to admire.  It is clear that Twitter owes a lot of its success to the star making machinery behind the popular song:

    Judging by the numbers alone, Twitter is more deeply intertwined with music than any other industry. Four of the top five—and half of the top 20—most-followed Twitter accounts are solo musicians. More than movie stars or major athletes, whose work is more obviously collaborative and done according to others’ scripts, the pop star/fan relationship maximizes what Twitter does best, fostering emotional connections rooted in the personal authenticity of a single, spectacular figure. This has led to an environment where millions of Twitter users are there purely to serve as foot soldiers in their idol’s digital army, and where the tantalizing (or mortifying) possibility of direct contact is always present.

    Maybe it’s time that Twitter did the right thing and stopped abusing the absurdly outdated DMCA safe harbor game of whack a mole.  Please let’s not be told that Twitter’s value is exposure or that data is worth having your rights ignored.  Data may be the new exposure, but you do have to ask how do people like Jack Dorsey sleep at night.

    Share this:

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Email
    • Reddit
    • LinkedIn
    • Tumblr
    • Pinterest

    Like this:

    Like Loading...

    Related

    Posted in Artist Rights, Artists Rights WatchTagged Chris Castle, Eric Harvey, Music Twitter, Pitchfork

    Post navigation

    Previous Guest Post by @cagoldberglaw:  Scared as Hell: Section 230 Denies Access to Justice, Not Free Speech Protection via @musictechpolicy
    Next TikTok: Nothing Says Chinese State Influence like Censorship and Mass Copyright Infringement Pt I

    Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts. You can set for daily or weekly notifications.

    Artist Rights Watch

    Follow Artist Rights Watch, the news source for the Artist Rights Movement

    Follow The Trichordist on Twitter

    • RT @jason_kint: ok, let's do this. I've now read all 153 pages of United States vs Google filed earlier today. As I've said earlier, Google… 4 days ago
    • RT @jason_kint: Adding this to the end here, my thread after reading the thing ;) twitter.com/jason_kint/sta… 4 days ago
    • RT @jason_kint: “Here are just five examples” rattling off details of alleged anticompetitive behavior. It’s notable there are once again e… 4 days ago
    Follow @thetrichordist

    Recent Posts

    • Comment to Copyright Office on Termination, the Black Box and Lawlessness at MLC
    • @northmusicgroup Calls Out The MLC’s Ability to Make “Law” Through Business Rules that Hurt Songwriters and Skew the Black Box to Benefit Majors — Artist Rights Watch/Music Technology Policy
    • Are Songwriters and Artists Financing Inflation With Their Credit Cards? — Music Tech Solutions
    • @davidclowery: Silicon Valley’s Loophole Arbitrage on Display Yet Again with OpenAI
    • No Hits, No Hit Records: The Streaming Mechanicals Poverty Program at the CRB
    • Urgent call to action! Call @SenatorLeahy to Support the American Music Fairness Act (202) 224-4242
    • @repdarrellissa on #AMFA: The right number is not zero #IRespectMusic
    • Artist Rights Symposium III at @TerryCollege at UGA, Keynote by @MMercuriadis of @HipgnosisSongs
    • Senator Leahy Says Show Me the Money on the MLC’s Black Box
    • Trickle-Down Streaming Mechanical Royalties Will be Be Up for Discussion

    Categories

    Archives

    Is Your Band Registered to Vote? Click here to find out from CanIVote.org!

    Vote for artist rights in local elections!
    Blog at WordPress.com.
    • Follow Following
      • The Trichordist
      • Join 7,572 other followers
      • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
      • The Trichordist
      • Customize
      • Follow Following
      • Sign up
      • Log in
      • Copy shortlink
      • Report this content
      • View post in Reader
      • Manage subscriptions
      • Collapse this bar
    %d bloggers like this: