The Trichordist

Artists For An Ethical and Sustainable Internet #StopArtistExploitation

Main menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • additional documents
  • || About ||
    • || The 101: Essential Reading (FAQ) ||
      • || Comment Policy and Copyright ||
  • || Videos ||
  • || Practical Knowledge ||
  • || Submit A Story ||
  • || International Translations ||
  • || Advocacy Updates ||

Search

  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
October 18, 2019

Guest Post: @ericdharvey Misses Music Twitter’s Defining Feature: Refuse Licenses and Pay Zero Royalties via @ArtistRights Watch

by Chris Castle

Eric Harvey has a great must-read article in Pitchfork about what he describes as “Music Twitter” (“How Twitter Changed Music“).  Mr. Harvey makes that case that Twitter was designed with both music and the music business in mind.  That is certainly true.  Twitter couldn’t be a more perfect way for pop and rap stars to connect with their fans and introduce new music.  If willing to put in the time (aka free labor for Twitter), artists from any genre can find it useful.  Unbelievable numbers of recordings are promoted, linked, streamed and talked about on Twitter.

Mr. Harvey makes a point that many of us probably didn’t know:

When Twitter was dreamed up, in fact, it was with music in mind. “This is why we built this thing! For concerts and music shows!” Noah Glass told fellow co-founder Jack Dorsey in 2006, according to Nick Bilton’s book, Hatching Twitter. At that point, when the site had only a handful of users, Glass and Dorsey road-tested Twitter at Coachella and attempted a partnership with the 2007 VMAs. As the site grew in popularity, Bilton recounts, pop stars made pilgrimages to the company’s modest San Francisco headquarters, like when a couple of Twitter engineers “found a member of the band blink-182, half-asleep and half-drunk, pouring a small bottle of gin into a bowl of Fruity Pebbles cereal, then chowing down on breakfast.”

But after you read the post, I think you may realize that there’s a dog that didn’t bark–despite the fact that some of Jack Dorsey’s best friends may be musicians, Twitter has consistently refused to even accept the premise that the site needs licenses and should pay royalties.  However “intertwined” Twitter may be with the music business, the company steadfastly refuses to acknowledge that value by respecting business of the artists, songwriters, producers, musicians and vocalists who drive what Mr. Harvey shows pretty conclusively is a big chunk of Twitter’s value.

Mr. Harvey dives into the many connections between the company’s founders who designed their product to free ride on the artists they claim to admire.  It is clear that Twitter owes a lot of its success to the star making machinery behind the popular song:

Judging by the numbers alone, Twitter is more deeply intertwined with music than any other industry. Four of the top five—and half of the top 20—most-followed Twitter accounts are solo musicians. More than movie stars or major athletes, whose work is more obviously collaborative and done according to others’ scripts, the pop star/fan relationship maximizes what Twitter does best, fostering emotional connections rooted in the personal authenticity of a single, spectacular figure. This has led to an environment where millions of Twitter users are there purely to serve as foot soldiers in their idol’s digital army, and where the tantalizing (or mortifying) possibility of direct contact is always present.

Maybe it’s time that Twitter did the right thing and stopped abusing the absurdly outdated DMCA safe harbor game of whack a mole.  Please let’s not be told that Twitter’s value is exposure or that data is worth having your rights ignored.  Data may be the new exposure, but you do have to ask how do people like Jack Dorsey sleep at night.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

  • Posted by thetrichordist in Artist Rights, Artists Rights Watch
  • Tagged: Chris Castle, Eric Harvey, Music Twitter, Pitchfork

Post navigation

← Guest Post by @cagoldberglaw:  Scared as Hell: Section 230 Denies Access to Justice, Not Free Speech Protection via @musictechpolicy
TikTok: Nothing Says Chinese State Influence like Censorship and Mass Copyright Infringement Pt I →

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts. You can set for daily or weekly notifications.

Artist Rights Watch

Follow Artist Rights Watch, the news source for the Artist Rights Movement

MOST READ

  • 01 – The Streaming Price Bible – Spotify, YouTube and What 1 Million Plays Means to You!
  • 02 – Over 50 Major Brands Supporting Music Piracy, It’s Big Business!
  • 03 – My Song Got Played On Pandora 1 Million Times and All I Got Was $16.89
  • 04 – Record Labels Invest $4.5 Billion Annually In Artists… Pirates, $0… Any Questions?
  • 05 – Letter To Emily White @ NPR
  • 06 – New Boss Worse Than The Old Boss
  • 07 – Google, Advertising, Money and Piracy. A History of Wrongdoing Exposed.
  • 08 – If the Internet is working for Musicians, Why aren’t more Musicians Working Professionally?
  • 09 – Artists, Know They Enemy!
  • 10 – Two Simple Facts about Technology and Piracy : iTunes Vs. YouTube

Follow The Trichordist on Twitter

  • Every now and then the dog has to question the existence of the mirror twitter.com/vosto/status/1… 12 hours ago
  • Will Apple's Rumored Podcast Subscription Service Derail Spotify? finance.yahoo.com/m/73992dfc-c15… via @Yahoo 12 hours ago
  • RT @TheBlakeMorgan: The emperor has no clothes. #IRespectMusic "Spotify stock (SPOT) has dipped in value following a Citigroup rating drop… 12 hours ago
Follow @thetrichordist

Recent Posts

  • Songwriters Alarmed Biden Admin Looking at Google/Amazon Attorney for Antitrust Chief
  • Guest Post: Streaming and the Embarrassment of COVID Riches
  • Save the Date! January 14 at Noon CST, Zoom Panel with @musictechpolicy @northmusicgroup @sealeinthedeal for Independent Songwriters
  • Please take our Mechanical Licensing Collective Survey
  • Optimism is Contagious, Too: @nivassoc’s #SaveOurStages Included in COVID Stimulus–Update
  • Guest Post: What is the Intention of Justice? Notice and Stay Down is the Government’s Responsibility
  • Curiouser and Curiouser: Strange Loose Ends with Apple Music and The MLC
  • What is Apple Music Up to with the MLC?
  • “MILLION A MONTH” TIM IS BACK WITH NEW IMPROVED PROFITEERING–BUT #IRESPECTMUSIC @THEBLAKEMORGAN FIGHTS BACK–AGAIN
  • The DLC Finally Confirms (Sort Of) How Much is in the MMA Black Box–Bigger than a breadbox
  • As COVID Decimates State Revenues Tennessee Franchise Tax Comes for out of State Performers
  • Black Box Hunting: The Songwriters Guild/Society of Composers & Lyricists/Music Creators North America’s Ex Parte Letter Stands Up for Transparency
  • Guest Post: The False Double Payment Bottom of the MMA Black Box
  • Thank You @irvingazoff!
  • @digitalmusicnws Asks Is the MLC Putting Smaller Streaming Platforms Out of Business? — ArtistRightsWatch
  • Chris Castle’s Copyright Office Comments on the Black Box Controversy
  • MediaNet Trying to Cut Off Black Box Payments
  • SoundExchange Comment on The MLC’s Public Database
  • @CISACnews and BIEM’s Copyright Office Comments on the MLC
  • Future of Music Coalition Warns Against Vendor Lock-in in Copyright Office Comments

Spotify's Greatest Hits!

  • Apple Announces Itunes One Dollar Albums and Ten Cent Song Downloads In Time For The Holidays! | Sillycon Daily News
  • BUT SPOTIFY IS PAYING 70% OF GROSS TO ARTISTS, ISN’T THAT FAIR? NO, AND HERE’S WHY…
  • How to Fix Music Streaming in One Word, “Windows”… two more “Pay Gates”…
  • Jay Frank’s Magical Mystery Streaming Math… Or, Brotha Can Ya Spare A Calculator?
  • Music Streaming Math, Can It All Add Up?
  • Spotify Doesn’t Kill Music Sales like Smoking Doesn’t Cause Cancer…
  • Spotify’s Daniel Ek is Really Bad At Simple Math, “Artists Will Make a Decent Living Off Streaming In Just a Few Years”
  • Streaming Is the Future, Spotify Is Not. Let’s talk Solutions.
  • USA Spotify Streaming Rates Reveal 58% of Streams Are Free, Pays Only 16% Of Revenue
  • Who will be the First Fired Label Execs over Spotify Fiasco & Cannibalization?

Exploitation Economy

  • Aimee Mann Exploited by Russian Brides, Wells Fargo Bank and Nationwide Insurance
  • Billy Corgan Exploited By… Citi Bank, AT&T, Target, Virgin Atlantic, Mazda, Neiman Marcus, Musicians Friend, Hertz, BMW, Audi, Boston Market, Urban Outfitters, Williams Sonoma
  • Dead Kennedys Exploited by Charter, Blizzard, @AlaskaAir and @1800Flowers
  • Dirty Money, Profits From Piracy [video]
  • Jared Leto Exploited by Rapidshare, VW, Go Pro, LG, Emirates Airlines, Adobe, Ford and Target
  • Lou Reed Exploited By American Express, AT&T, Chevorlet, Chili’s, Lysol, Pottery Barn, Vons, Domino’s Pizza, Netflix, Galaxy Nexus and Ron Jeremy!
  • Lyric Pirates Supported by Big Business…
  • MegaUpload (MegaVideo) Smoking Gun? Did the site illegally charge for Streaming Movies? (Star Wars)
  • Neil Young Exploited by Ford, Cooper Mini, Target, State Farm, Adobe, Alaska Air, ATT, Boy Scouts, DIRECTV, LG, Princess Cruises, HP, Westin, Charmin, RapidShare
  • Neko Case Exploited by Macy’s, Levi’s, Princess Cruises, Skype, Yahoo, Marvel and Electronic Arts
  • Talib Kweli Exploited by State Farm Insurance, Neiman Marcus, Ferguson/Kohler, The Ad Council, Google, Ad Choices and Desk Top Strippers
  • Tom Waits Exploited By Wendy’s, Yahoo, BMW, Mitt Romney, Adobe, Cadillac, LG, Target, Westin Hotels, Priceline, Hyatt Hotels, Weight Watchers, VISA, State Farm, Mini Cooper, ADT Security…
  • U2 Exploited by United Airlines, Jet Blue, HP, State Farm, Westin, Urban Outfitters, Sprint, AT&T, Amazon, Disney Resorts, Crate and Barrel

Pandora Joins Evil (IRFA)

  • * Bad News, Good News, Bad News. Internet Radio “Fairness” Act Sponsor and Conservative UT Congressman Chaffetz Taunts Musicians; Admits to Belief in Evolution; Urges Government Interference In Markets.
  • * Four Simple Reasons Why the Pandora Radio Act Screws Musicians (EZ Reader)
  • * IRFA and the Future of Music Policy Summit: Why Would FOMC Miss An Opportunity to Defend Artist Rights?
  • * IRFA is the Broadcast Industry’s SOPA. Censors Free Speech
  • * Is Tim Westergren (Pandora) Really Just A Beard For Clear Channel?
  • * Lobbyist For CCIA Makes All Kinds of Wild Claims About Copyright Management Organizations. BMI ASCAP SOCAN SAMI Included in Charges of Corruption.
  • * Muzzling Free Speech By Artists: IRFA Section 5 Analysis
  • * Pandora Comes Out Of The Closet; Confirms Clear Channel and Pandora “More Than Just Friends’
  • * Sign the @musiciansunion (AFM) Letter: Friends don’t let friends get IRFA’d!
  • * Untruth in Advertising: Pandora’s Misleading Plea To Listeners On Behalf Of The Internet Radio “Fairness” Act.

Categories

Blogroll

  • 300 Songs
  • Ad Land
  • Andreas Ekstrom
  • Andrew Orlowski's Excellent Column at The Register @regvulture
  • Copy Like
  • Copyhype
  • Copyright Alliance
  • Copyright And Technology
  • Cynical Musician
  • Dean's List
  • Ethical Fan
  • Fareplay
  • Helienne Lindvall's Excellent Column at the Guardian @helienne
  • I Buy My Music
  • Jeremy Nicholl
  • Ladies of the Canyon
  • Popup Pirates–Ellen Seidler's blog
  • The Illusion Of More
  • The Lonestar Rollergirls
  • Unionosity

Archives

ethical internet

Is Your Band Registered to Vote? Click here to find out from CanIVote.org!

Vote for artist rights on November 4!

    David Lowery

    • _ Meet The New Boss, Worse Than The Old Boss?
    • _ Mellencamp Character Assassination. The New Republic Bravely Stands Up For Corporations and Criminal Groups That Exploit Artists.
    • _ The Most Important Fact Academics and The Copyleft Neglect to Mention: Copyright is Optional.
    • _ Video of the “Radio Active” panel at The Future of Music Summit 2012.
    • _ You Can’t Have A Have A Healthy Market Economy Without Property Rights. Why Do So Many In Tech Blogosphere Want To Abolish Cyber Property Rights And Cripple The Cyber-Economy?

    You Should Know!

    • Why Spotify is not Netflix (But Maybe It Should Be)
    • _ Fortune 500 Advertising Pirates
    • _ How Copyright Encourages Innovation in Hollywood
    • _ IFRA is SOPA Against Musicians (Pandora Censorship Act)
    • _ Infringement Really Is Theft
    • _ John Perry Barlow Is Wrong! (EFF)
    • _ Larry Lessig Is Wrong! (Creative Commons)
    • _ SF Gate Blunders Piracy Facts
    • _ The Bad Science and Greed Behind the "IP is Inhibiting Innovation Argument"
    • _ The Sky Is RIsing : Magic Beaver Edition

    Dig Deeper

    • _ Artists For An Ethical Internet
    • _ Artists Have Rights Too
    • _ Empty Threats from Freehadists "We're Gonna Boycott Your Band"
    • _ Enemies Of Artists Organize on Internet
    • _ How Tech Policy Cripples The Information Economy
    • _ Mike Lombardo Smackdown [video]
    • _ Smells Like Pirate Desperation…
    • _ Spotify is NOT Good For Artists…
    • _ Streaming Price Index : What Artists Get Paid
    • _ The Human Rights Of Artists

    Guest Posts

    • _ 1,000 True Fans (an answer) by Robert Rich
    • _ Are You Worthy? by Doña Oxford
    • _ Mark Isham Guest Post – Artists Deserve To Be Compensated For Their Work
    • _ Music NOT Like Water By Gavin Casleton
    • _ Occupy Artists Rights by Chris Whitten
    • _ Piracy Counter Arguments by Zach Hemsey
    • _ The Paradox Of Pirate Logic by Chris Whitten

    Contact

    You can contact us by sending an email directly to : the trichordist (one word) at mail dot com.
Blog at WordPress.com.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
%d bloggers like this: