The Sirius legal smackdown means things don’t look so good for Pandora…
Rut ro. For those of you following along, remember that Flo & Eddie won a tremendous victory against SiriusXM on a motion for summary judgement in federal court before U.S. District Judge Philip Gutierrez in California in a putative class action on behalf of all pre-72 recordings.
Sirius appealed the Turtles case.
Also recall that the major labels filed a separate case in California state court before California Superior Court Judge Mary H. Strobel. The labels essentially won that case when California Judge Strobel followed similar reasoning to federal Judge Gutierrez . However, the California judge handed down her opinion after Sirius filed its appeal in the federal case applying California law.
So because Sirius lost both cases, the Turtles may be able to stop the Sirius appeal in the band’s federal court case if they can rely on the decision in the major label State court case.
Two parallel cases in…
View original post 711 more words